Best viewed in IE 4.0+
Your Daily Fantasy Rx
Fantasy Review of Philadelphia Prospects

by Tim Polko

Today's Fantasy Rx

I find it difficult to fault the Phillies' farm system since they have produced Randy Wolf, Pat Burrell, Marlon Anderson, Jimmy Rollins, Brandon Duckworth, and Brett Myers over the past few years. They also have not made a bad first round pick in a decade, selecting Wayne Gomes, Carlton Loewer, Reggie Taylor, Adam Eaton, J.D. Drew, Burrell, Myers, Chase Utley, Gavin Floyd, and Cole Hamels in 2002. Every one of these players should continue playing in the majors for the next few years, a rather amazing accomplishment considering several teams barely drafted a couple major leaguers in the first round. However the Phillies need to push for a championship in the next few years, and losing Scott Rolen has definitely hurt them. Once Marlon Byrd and either Utley or Travis Chapman reach the majors, only Floyd and Hamels appear very likely to contribute in Philadelphia. Fortunately the farm system's produced so much talent over the past several years that they might be able to withstand the loss of Rolen while improving their record in the next couple seasons as they head into a new ballpark in 2004. Of course, the current lack of depth hurts them in trade talks and reduces the likelihood of sustaining success, but they can afford one or two bad drafts if they can keep top players like Bobby Abreu and Burrell under contract for the next few years.

The focus of this offseason for Philadelphia must be to take advantage of ownership's reported willingness to significantly increase the payroll. Signing Pat Burrell to a long-term deal is the top priority, and extended contracts for Randy Wolf and Jimmy Rollins would not hurt. Next, they need to sign a productive right-handed bat to hit second, and Edgardo Alfonzo fits perfectly here (as he does for several other teams). Philly should slot him at second base given that Chase Utley is ready to play third in the majors, giving them in intriguing top-of-the-order of Rollins, Alfonzo, Abreu, and Burrell. Catcher Mike Lieberthal, Utley, and rookie centerfielder Marlon Byrd comprise the bottom of the order, so the key is how to address the gaping power vacancy in the #5 hole. Fortunately the missing position is first base, and since Bowa shows no willingness to start Jeremy Giambi every day, Philly should look to package Giambi and current 2B starter Marlon Anderson for a significant source of offense at first. If they can someone sign Jim Thome, Abreu can hit 2nd, Alfonzo 3rd, Thome 4th, and Burrell 5th, but I expect Thome to stay in Cleveland. A trade, likely with an American League club, makes much more sense. Rafael Palmeiro and Carlos Delgado should be the top two targets, and a package involving Giambi should be sufficient for the latter. If Delgado will not waive his no-trade clause, then Nick Johnson and Steve Cox appear available for reasonable compensation.

Acquiring Johnson or Cox also leaves significant payroll resources available to address other areas of need. While Randy Wolf, Vicente Padilla, Brett Myers, and Brandon Duckworth are a solid foursome, especially when supported by Joe Roa and Eric Junge, Philadelphia desperately needs an ace and mentor for the youngsters. The search should begin and end with Greg Maddux, and even a $45M/3 year contract looks reasonable considering Maddux could help this staff grow into championship material. Gavin Floyd has significant potential, but he is a good three years away from reaching Philadelphia, and he could arrive in time to replace Maddux. Adding a veteran to this group is essential given the heavy workload sustained by Wolf and Padilla over the past few years, so Roa and Junge still will be needed as long relievers and injury replacements.

The bullpen situation is slightly more complicated as only Jose Mesa, Rheal Cormier, and perhaps Carlos Silva will return. Roa and Junge can help in long relief given the relative youth of the staff, however adding a dominant short reliever seems rather important. They probably should try to acquire bullpen help for the arbitration-eligible Travis Lee, although a free agent like Steve Reed or Ramiro Mendoza would add somewhat needed depth.

Philadelphia possesses an exceptional core of young and developing talent with no key member even over 30. While Lieberthal is currently 30, Johnny Estrada remains a superb backup option who is quite capable of starting and unfortunately seems likely to remain stuck behind Liebs for another couple of years. Everyone else is either in their prime or still developing as an athlete. Without much current depth in the system, Philly needs to win with a team based on their current collection of major leaguers, so even though the incompetence of management caused him to leave, hopefully Scott Rolen will be the last defection faced by this current group

Double-Digit Upside

Marlon Byrd, 25, OF-R
8/35 for .229/.250/.371 with 1 HR, 1 RBI, 2 R, 0/2 SB%,
and 1:8 BB:K in Philadelphia.
160/538 for .297/.362/.476 with 15 HR, 63 RBI, 103 R, 15/16 SB%,
and 46:98 BB:K at AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL).

As long as Byrd avoids off-field issues like reported domestic quarrels and adding excess weight on his normally ripped 6'0", 220 lbs. frame, he should emerge as an impressive major leaguer, though the Phillies probably wish Byrd was not emulating Kirby Puckett quite this explicitly. While he did not sustain the five-category growth of 2001 and only managed an .838 OPS in AAA, Byrd is still a much better player than Doug Glanville. There is no good reason for Byrd to spend any more time in the minors, and I am very comfortable bidding into double digits for someone likely to quickly emerge as the best rookie outfielder in the league.

Nick Punto, 24, 2B/SS-S
1/6 for .167/.167/.167 with 0 HR, 0 RBI, 0 R, 0/0 SB%,
and 0:3 BB:K in Philadelphia.
120/443 for .271/.378/.327 with 1 HR, 29 RBI, 74 R, 42/50 SB%,
and 76:84 BB:K at AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL).

Few players use the opportunity to repeat a level as well as Punto. While he still shows no power development, he bumped his base offensive skills from a .60 BB:K, .15 walk rate, and .75 contact rate to a .90 BB:K, .17 walk rate, and .81 contact rate. He even continued displaying very impressive speed. If the Phillies decided to give him a chance to start at second base, Punto could combine with Jimmy Rollins to give Philly two very speedy switch-hitters at the top of the order. However he is far more likely to stay a reserve, though know that he is a great Dollar Days selection because of his one-category upside.

Chase Utley, 23, 3B-L
122/464 for .263/.352/.461 with 17 HR, 70 RBI, 73 R, 8/11 SB%,
and 46:89 BB:K at AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL).

Through 20 games and 80 at-bats in the AFL, he is mashing the ball for a .350/.393/.575 line, and he has only committed one error in 16 games in the field. Philadelphia selected him with the 15th overall pick of the 2000 draft out of UCLA, and despite jumping him to A+ and then straight to AAA this year, Utley has developed into an intriguing offensive player who should provide the Phillies with more offense than someone like Placido Polanco. Keeping him in the minors any longer makes no sense considering Utley responded wonderfully to Philadelphia challenging him with two double-promotions in two years. I would probably stop bidding just short of $10 due to his weak overall skills, but since Philly wanted him ready to replace Rolen, there is no reason to give Utley more development time now.

Reserve Help

Travis Chapman, 24, 3B-R
144/478 for .301/.388/.473 with 15 HR, 76 RBI, 64 R, 3/4 SB%,
and 54:77 BB:K at AA Reading(EL).

Chosen over five hundred picks after Chase Utley in 2000, Chapman possesses stronger and more consistent offensive skills, and he could easily steal the third base job in a year or two. I cannot imagine any circumstances in which Philly would let him start over Utley in 2003 due to Chapman's need for AAA development time, however his future appears rather bright. I would only spend a low pick since either Utley or Chapman seems likely trade bait sometime next year, however once he finds a clear path to a major league third base job, I expect he will start contributing to roto teams very quickly.

Eric Valent, 25, OF-L
2/10 for .200/.200/.200 with 0 HR, 0 RBI, 1 R, 0/0 SB%,
and 0:3 BB:K in Philadelphia.
137/546 for .251/.311/.370 with 9 HR, 84 RBI, 69 R, 0/2 SB%,
and 49:94 BB:K at AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL).

Forced to repeat AAA even though he appeared ready to compete either for a corner slot or a straight backup position, Valent demonstrated far less longball power and greatly reduced his immediate upside as a prospect. He is no longer worth a $1 gamble for many owners, and I would prefer to wait until I see what playing time he will find before rostering him in deeper leagues.

Geoff Geary, 26, RH Swingman
4-2 on 82:32 K:BB in 101 IP over 38 G(8GS) with 108 H, 9 HR,
and a 3.03 ERA at AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL).

Geary continued to display very good command while pitching in his first full season at AAA. He still can struggle at times but his overall skills are rather good and he is close to meriting an extended look in the majors. Whenever Geary starts posting solid skills in the majors, feel free to roster him at that time since his statistical history would support major league success.

Eric Junge, 25, RH Swingman
2-0 on 11:5 K:BB in 12.2 IP over 1 GS(4G) with 14 H, 0 HR,
and a 1.42 ERA in Philadelphia.
12-6 on 126:67 K:BB in 180.2 IP over 29 GS with 170 H, 16 HR
and a 3.54 ERA at AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL).

Acquired from Los Angeles last year in the Omar Daal trade, Junge emerged as the best pitching prospect above A-ball in the system once Brett Myers reached the majors. While he has never displayed much dominance, he could definitely help some roto teams if he can limit his walks. Do not expect a fantastic season from him in 2003, although he will be worth owning in some leagues.

Elio Serrano, 23, RH Reliever
1-3 on 45:17 K:BB in 71 IP over 43 G with 64 H, 6 HR,
and a 2.92 ERA at AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL).

Philly let him pitch for three years in short-season ball before finally promoting him to full-season A-ball in 2000, and then they only needed two years to push him to AAA. I am concerned about his rather troublesome drop in strikeouts, however Serrano also maintained his excellent command. He appears likely to succeed if given opportunity in the majors, although I do not see sufficient upside to warrant an active attempt to acquire him.

Evan Thomas, 28, RH Starter
10-2 on 75:37 K:BB in 113 IP over 20 GS(22G) with 106 H, 6 HR
and a 3.90 ERA at AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL).

While he has demonstrated excellent command for the last five years at the top levels of the system, Thomas still has not reached the majors due to his lack of dominance. Now he is free to seek gainful employment elsewhere as a minor league free agent, but after the success of Red Barons teammate Joe Roa, I think Thomas might return for another year in the Scranton area. He is essentially ready for the majors, however, despite his intriguing minor league numbers, I would want to see him continue posting strong command ratios in the majors before taking a chance on him.

Pete Zamora, 27, LH Reliever
5-2 and 15 Saves on 32:29 K:BB in 62 IP over 55 G with 63 H, 2 HR,
and a 3.48 ERA at AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL).

Zamora appeared likely to break camp in the majors until the Phillies traded for Hector Mercado. Consequently he went back to AAA and pitched effectively as a part-time closer, but his skills indicate practically no room for 2003 improvement. Avoid Zamora for the indefinite future.

Minor League Draft

Gavin Floyd, 19, RH Starter
11-10 on 140:64 K:BB in 166 IP over 27 GS with 119 H, 13 HR,
and a 2.77 ERA at A Lakewood(Sal).

The #4 overall pick from last year's draft, Floyd owns strong skills across the board but definitely appears to need another few years of development time. He carries the same injury risk as all good high school pitchers, so combined with a strikeout rate below the level we would like to see from a draft-worthy A-ball pitcher, only the relative lack of competition in the Phillies' system makes Floyd a reasonable pick. You should probably avoid him in most leagues.

Wait 'til 2004
(Each player listed with the highest level they reached in 2002.)

Kris Bennett, 23, A+ Clearwater(FSL) IF-R
Uriel Casillas, 27, AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL) 3B-R
Nate Espy, 24, AA Reading(EL) 1B-R
Troy Farnsworth, 26, A+ Clearwater(FSL) 1B-R
P.J. Forbes, 25, AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL) 2B/OF-R
Dan Gonzalez, 20, A Lakewood(Sal) SS-S
Manny Gonzalez, 26, AA Reading(EL) OF-S
Buzz Hannahan, 26, AA Reading(EL) 2B-R
Anthony Hensley, 24, A+ Clearwater(FSL) OF_S
Brian Hitchcox, 24, AA Reading(EL) OF-R
Ryan Howard, 22, A Lakewood(Sal) 1B-L
Anderson Machado, 21, AA Reading(EL) SS-S
Troy McNaughton, 27, AA Reaing(EL) OF-L
Ryan Howard, 22, A Lakewood(Sal) 1B-L
Jorge Padilla, 23, AA Reading(EL) OF-R
Rod Perry, 23, A+ Clearwater(FSL) OF-R
Jeff Phelps, 23, A Lakewood(Sal) 3B-R
Juan Richardson, 23, A+ Clearwater(FSL) 3B-R
J.P. Roberge, 30, AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL) 1B-R
Carlos Rodriguez, 19, A- Batavia(NYP) SS-S
Jay Sitzman, 24, AA Reading(EL) OF-L
Ken Woods, 32, AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL) OF-R
Scott Youngbauer, 23, A+ Clearwater(FSL) 2B/SS-S

Daniel Adams, 24, AA Reading(EL) RH Reliever
Ezequiel Astacio, 22, A Lakewood(Sal) RH Starter
Brad Baisley, 23, AA Reading(EL) RH Starter
Eude Brito, 24, A+ Clearwater(FSL) LH Reliever
Frank Brooks, 24, AA Reading(EL) LH Reliever
Taylor Buchholz, 20, AA Reading(EL) RH Starter
Keith Bucktrot, 21, A+ Clearwater(FSL) RH Starter
Taft Cable, 22, A Lakewood(Sal) RH Starter
Ryan Carter, 23, A+ Clearwater(FSL) LH Starter
Jesus Cordero, 23, A+ Clearwater(FSL) RH Reliever
Layne Dawson, 23, A Lakewood(Sal) RH Swingman
Vinny DeChristofaro, 20, A Lakewood(Sal) LH Starter
Andy Elskamp, 24, A+ Clearwater(FSL) RH Reliever
Martire Franco, 24, AA Reading(EL) RH Starter
Jimmy Hamilton, 27, AA Reading(EL) LH Reliever
Yoel Hernandez, 20, A+ Clearwater(FSL) RH Starter
Cary Hiles, 26, AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL) RH Reliever
Ryan Hutchison, 24, A+ Clearwater(FSL) RH Reliever
Il Kim, 22, A Lakewood(Sal) RH Reliever
Greg Kubes, 25, AA Reading(EL) LH Starter
Seung Lee, 23, AA Reading(EL) RH Starter
Ryan Madison, 22, A+ Clearwater(FSL) RH Starter in '01; injured in '02
Brandon Mayfield, 24, A+ Clearwater(FSL) RH Reliever
Sam McConnell, 26, AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL) LH Swingman
Josh Miller, 23, A+ Clearwater(FSL) RH Reliever
Brad Pautz, 25, AA Reading(EL) RH Reliever
Frank Perez, 24, AA Reading(EL) RH Swingman
Ken Pumphrey, 26, AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL) RH Starter
Carlos Silverio, 23, A Lakewood(Sal) RH Reliever
Matt Squires, 23, A Lakewood(Sal) LH Reliever
Rob Tejeda, 20, A+ Clearwater(FSL) RH Starter
Eric Weaver, 29, AA Reading(EL) RH Reliever
Jeremy Wedel, 25, AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre(IL) LH Reliever
Mike Wilson, 22, A+ Clearwater(FSL) RH Swingman

As I suggested at the beginning of this column, Philadelphia currently possesses very little minor league depth anywhere in the system except perhaps third base. Marlon Byrd is an excellent candidate for Rookie of the Year, and guys like Nick Punto, Chase Utley, Travis Chapman, and Eric Junge should emerge as complementary pieces in the majors. However I do not see much projectable talent other than the current top prospects of Byrd, Utley, Chapman, and Gavin Floyd. The high immediate upside of Byrd and Utley at least provides for a favorable comparison with Houston's 2003 rookie class, and only the extremely high trade value of Brad Hawpe keeps Colorado above Philly.

Current organizational ranking by potentially helpful fantasy depth, based on both the quality and quantity of players ready to contribute in the majors, and consideration of the trade value of minor league draft picks from the lower levels of each system:

1. Minnesota Twins(M.Cuddyer, M.Restovich, T.Sears, L.Ford, J.Mauer, J.Morneau)
2. Cleveland Indians(B.Phillips, V.Martinez, A.Escobar, & a dozen young SP)
3. Texas Rangers(T.Hafner, M.Teixeira, R.Ludwick, J.Hart, Je.Clark, C.Lewis)
4. Chicago White Sox(J.Borchard, J.Rauch, M.Olivo, K.Honel)
5. Los Angeles Dodgers(J.Thurston, L.Allen, C-F.Chen, W.Ruan, J.Loney)
6. Anaheim Angels(F.Rodriguez, R.Quinlan, C.Bootcheck, C.Kotchman)
7. Arizona Diamondbacks(L.Overbay, J.Patterson, J.Valverde, O.Villarreal, C.Tracy)
8. Colorado Rockies(J.Cust, J.Young, C.Freeman, G.Atkins, B.Hawpe)
9. Philadelphia Phillies(M.Byrd, C.Utley, E.Junge, T.Chapman, G.Floyd)
10. Houston Astros(J.Lane, J.Robertson, B. Lidge, J.Buck, C.Burke)
11. New York Mets(A.Heilman, T.Wigginton, M.Scutaro, Jo.Reyes, J.Phillips)
12. Atlanta Braves(T.Hodges, M.Hessman, W.Betemit, A.Wainwright)
13. Florida Marlins(A.Nunez, J.Medrano, K.Hooper, Ad.Gonzalez, J.Stokes)
14. Oakland Athletics(E.German, R.Harden, J.Rheinecker, J. Arnold, J-F.Griffin)
15. Seattle Mariners(W.Bloomquist, C.Snelling, J.Strong, C.Nagoette, T.Blackley)
16. Detroit Tigers(E.Munson, F.German, O.Infante, A.Torres, J.Bonderman)
17. Chicago Cubs(H.S.Choi, F.Beltran, D.Kelton, S.Smyth, B.Harris)
18. Kansas City Royals(I.Ferguson, K.Harvey, J.Gobble, A.Gomez)
19. Cincinnati Reds(B.Larson, L.Hudson, W.M.Pena, J.Hall, R.Olmedo)
20. Tampa Bay Devil Rays(R.Baldelli, L.Carter, D.Brazelton, J.Gomes(x2))
21. Toronto Blue Jays(J.Werth, K.Cash, S.Fagan, G.Gross, M.Smith, F.Rosario)
22. New York Yankees(J.Rivera, D.Henson, J.DePaula)
23. Milwaukee Brewers(K.Ginter, J.Rushford, P.Liriano, M.Jones, P.Fielder)
24. Boston Red Sox(K.Youkilis, F.Sanchez)
25. Montreal Expos(R.Calloway, J.Carroll, V.Pascucci, T.Sledge, S.Song)
26. Baltimore Orioles(E.Bedard)

Today's Fantasy Rx: Nick Punto should provide an excellent return in Dollar Days, and I am also quite pleased with the upside of Eric Junge, who could earn several dollars if he can keep his walks down.

As we are attending the AFL Symposium this weekend, we will be unable to reply to e-mail until later next week. However we will continue posting new columns every day, and I expect to complete these prospect reviews before spending several days discussing news and notes from Arizona.

Click here to read the previous article.

Please e-mail your comments to
Advertise on
All content ©2001-18 Rotohelp, Inc. All rights reserved. PO Box 72054 Roselle, IL 60172.
Please send your comments, suggestions, and complaints to: